Sycamore CrossFit

Sycamore CrossFit

GymHappy Review:

"Beginners Find Confidence Without Intimidation"

5 /5

80 verified member reviews

What Members Are Saying

At Sycamore CrossFit, members enjoy a welcoming atmosphere that caters to both fitness beginners and those recovering from injuries.

  • ❤️ Fitness Beginners Find Confidence: Newcomers express gratitude for the coaches' personalized attention, with many noting how the scaling of workouts helps them feel successful and less intimidated as they embark on their fitness journey.
  • ❤️ Injury Recovery Participants Feel Supported: Reviewers appreciate the instructors’ attentiveness to individual needs, often highlighting how coaches provide modifications and adjustments to ensure workouts are both safe and effective.
  • ❤️ Personal Accountability Keeps You on Track: Members report that the coaches frequently check in on their progress, offering constructive feedback that enhances their motivation to return and engage consistently.
  • ❤️ Community Connections Foster Motivation: Many highlight the camaraderie among members, describing a supportive environment where encouragement and shared experiences make each workout enjoyable and rewarding.

AI summary based on recent reviews, updated weekly

Member Reviews

Gwen had always been so helpful to fine me tips on how to pick the movement that will help me improve overtime, it’s nice having someone to guide you through the workouts so you eventually reach your goal!

Verified Review
Feb 13, 2026
Review for Gwendolyn Henderson

Gwen is very helpful with bettering technique, personalizing workout scales, and keeping you motivated. She is a great coach!

Verified Review
Feb 9, 2026
Review for Gwendolyn Henderson

Her attention to detail is so helpful! She takes time to explain what you’re doing right and if you need to tweak it. She gives great positive encouragement. Makes each class fun and wanting me to come back!

Verified Review
Feb 8, 2026
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Chris is a coach who is watching when I don’t even know it to ensure I have proper form and technique. His coaching style offers suggestions that are easy to understand and implement. I enjoy is laid back approach and ideas to push myself.

Verified Review
Feb 4, 2026
Review for Chris Robinson

Love Michelle! She is so knowledgeable and supportive. Pushes you accordingly and gives alternatives when necessary. I'm blessed to have her as a coach!

Verified Review
Feb 3, 2026
Review for Michelle Buntrock

I am new to CrossFit. Nathan really helped me scale the workout today to help me feel successful, yet get a good workout without hurting myself. I am 2 weeks in and really enjoy the variety of workouts. Feeling better already….very sore, but in a good way. :).

Verified Review
Jan 30, 2026
Review for Nathan Knorreck

Verified Review
Jan 30, 2026
Review for Chris Robinson

Small details- “push with your whole foot doing deadlift…” real feedback I can use that helps me do it right is what Carl as well as all the coaches are great at. I’ve steadily increased my strength by paying attention to these small details and appreciate them for it. Especially during the many micro conversations throughout the session a lot is learned.

Verified Review
Jan 28, 2026
Review for Carl Balentyne

Verified Review
Jan 28, 2026
Review for Rebecca Loomis

Verified Review
Jan 28, 2026
Review for Chris Robinson

Chris has been great! I am newer to CrossFit and he always is helping me figure out what scale would work best for me. My confidence has grown significantly in the short amount of time I’ve been there.

Verified Review
Jan 26, 2026
Review for Chris Robinson

Rebecca is amazing! She’s encouraging and provides specific feedback to help me reach my goals!❤️

Verified Review
Jan 22, 2026
Review for Rebecca Loomis

Sue is a great coach! She is patient and really takes the time to guide me through each movement, making sure my form is correct and the pace feels right for my level. She’s helpful in suggesting adjustments when something feels too difficult and encouraging in a way that makes me want to keep going even when it gets tough. Sue is fun and I get a good workout tailored to my level, with a good mix of strength and cardio that leaves me feeling strong and energized after class.

Verified Review
Jan 22, 2026
Review for Sue Plote

Verified Review
Jan 20, 2026
Review for Carl Balentyne

Michelle is always so great with my daughter. She speaks to her like an equal and not like a little child. She is so positive and motivates her in a way that I cannot. Penelope leaves in a great mood with growing confidence every single time. We love Michelle!

Verified Review
Jan 20, 2026
Review for Michelle Buntrock

The coaching was top notch!

Verified Review
Jan 17, 2026
Review for Rebecca Loomis

Verified Review
Jan 16, 2026
Review for Rebecca Loomis

Michelle is great! She is always positive and always fun

Verified Review
Jan 14, 2026
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Jan 14, 2026

I attended my first CrossFit class ever last night and I absolutely loved it! I’ve done kickboxing, soccer, weight training, personal training but I’ve always found it could never keep my interest. It always feels like a chore but a class or two a week of this would be so manageable I absolutely loved the pace of the class and how each exercise built onto the next. My trainer also was able to explain the purpose of each lift and give more precise pointers in one class than any coach I’ve ever had has given. I’m currently trying to recruit some friends to go with I loved it so much!

Verified Review
Jan 9, 2026
Review for Carl Balentyne

Coach Gwen is awesome! Love the CrossFit community!

Verified Review
Jan 9, 2026
Review for Gwendolyn Henderson

I just recently started group classes at Sycamore CrossFit , and it's been great. Carl has run the classes I've taken so far. I appreciate how present and attentive he is, especially with form and pacing. I never felt rushed or lost in the group. The workouts are challenging but well explained, and scaling feels normal, not awkward. The gym is clean, organized, and runs smoothly, which makes it easy to focus on the work instead of the logistics. What stands out most is the overall feel. It's focused but relaxed, supportive without being overbearing. First impressions matter, and this was a good one.

Verified Review
Jan 9, 2026
Review for Carl Balentyne

Verified Review
Jan 9, 2026
Review for Carl Balentyne

Gwen is confident, knowledgeable, and cheerful. She has a contagious smile and motivates us to be our best. Five stars!

Verified Review
Jan 9, 2026
Review for Gwendolyn Henderson

Verified Review
Jan 7, 2026

Verified Review
Jan 6, 2026

Michelle is awesome! She knows how to customize a movement for each individual in class and also challenge them in a safe way. She always observes and gives great constructive feedback on how to improve the skill we are working on!

Verified Review
Jan 5, 2026
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Michelle does such a great job of making hard classes fun. Super laid back approach with a great attention to detail.

Verified Review
Jan 3, 2026
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Jan 2, 2026

Michelle has helped me make numerous modifications as I navigate the workouts around an injury that is quite painful. I’m grateful for the time she takes to think of alternatives that keep me engaged in the workouts while helping me stay motivated!

Verified Review
Dec 28, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

First class in a month so was taking it light. Carl understood that and didn't push but made sure my technique was correct.

Verified Review
Dec 22, 2025
Review for Carl Balentyne

Verified Review
Dec 22, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Carl always pays close attention to my skill work and makes sure I am always doing it correctly and safely.

Verified Review
Dec 10, 2025
Review for Carl Balentyne

Verified Review
Dec 5, 2025

Gwen is always so positive in class and creates a great energy.

Verified Review
Dec 2, 2025
Review for Gwendolyn Henderson

Michelle has helped me so much in the past year! When I started CrossFit I was a 69 year old in rehab. (Especially mentally) Michelle has made me a believer in myself, pushed me when needed, patted on the back when successful. All this help, and still fun to chat with! While she is a great coach, she is even a better person! While the star ratings go 1 to 5, she gets 10 stars from me! **********

Verified Review
Dec 1, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Dec 1, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

What was the highlight of today's workout? Learning modifications that help me scribe my fitness goals. The coach at Sycamore CrossFit took the time to explain each adjustment clearly, showing me how to adapt movements without losing their effectiveness. It felt empowering to discover ways to tailor the workout to my current abilities while still pushing toward progress. This personalized approach made the session feel not only challenging but also achievable, which keeps me motivated to come back and improve. Being able to connect my goals directly to the exercises gave the workout real purpose, and I left feeling confident about my path forward.

Verified Review
Dec 1, 2025
Review for Carl Balentyne

Verified Review
Nov 27, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

I appreciated the positive feedback on my form, I also appreciated him showing concern for my shoulder which has been a point of concern for a while.

Verified Review
Nov 19, 2025
Review for Carl Balentyne

Michelle is awesome. She’s a great coach, but more importantly she’s a great person and a big cheerleader. Always greets us with a smile, guides us through the lifts, and pushes us to do our best. Thanks Michelle!

Verified Review
Nov 17, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Nov 13, 2025

Sue is very encouraging and adapts the workout to my capabilities but also gently increasing the difficulty.

Verified Review
Nov 12, 2025
Review for Sue Plote

Verified Review
Nov 12, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 11, 2025

First time back in a CrossFit box in 10 years. Carl coached the morning session and stacked up a nice WOD mixing cardio and pull-ups. Afterwards, members there came up and gave me fist bumps and kudos for job well done and Welcome to Sycamore CrossFit. The community and coaches attention given to each member is just what I need right now. Will be back!

Verified Review
Nov 4, 2025

Coach Rebecca did great. Listened to my adaptation needs, but coached me thoroughly and confidently during the entire workout.

Verified Review
Oct 31, 2025

Verified Review
Oct 31, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Oct 30, 2025
Review for Nathan Knorreck

Coach Michelle is great! I love having her as a coach. She always has a positive attitude and a contagious smile. She’s very encouraging and makes sure to check in with everyone individually prior to the start of the workout.

Verified Review
Oct 30, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Oct 28, 2025

I have been so nervous to come back and Sue makes every class feel like you belong. She’s so supportive, explains things well, and offers great guidance on where to challenge or taking it slow. She constantly checks on certain movements for participants when it involves a known injury or challenge. It has made coming back so much less stressful and fun :) appreciate sue!

Verified Review
Oct 23, 2025
Review for Sue Plote

Great job. I've never been disappointed when attending any of her classes.

Verified Review
Oct 21, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Great workout. Super kind people. A lot of laughs. Coach kept us moving and gave great instructions along the way. I would highly recommend attending a class. If you are new, the hardest part is walking through the door, after that the coach walks you through every step of the way.

Verified Review
Oct 11, 2025
Review for Gwendolyn Henderson

Verified Review
Oct 4, 2025

I have attended 5 or 6 workouts so far. Great facility! Welcoming community and supportive coaches. Highly recommend!!

Verified Review
Oct 1, 2025

Michelle is awesome! She does an excellent job of breaking down the movements so you feel comfortable in the workout.

Verified Review
Sep 27, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Sep 4, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Michelle is a great coach! She always has modifications ready for me, helps me with my form and motivates me. She encourages me to try harder without being a drill sergeant type of coach- I love when she coaches class- we laugh a lot, high five and get a good work out in. I’m learning so much from her and the sycamore CrossFit team.

Verified Review
Aug 29, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Michelle is positive, encouraging and always there to assure you are pushing yourself! She’s observant on form and conscious of any injuries! Love having a class with Michelle!!!

Verified Review
Aug 6, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Coach Jake took his time to show me some ways to improve my movements, and was kind while explaining. It was a great class.

Verified Review
Aug 4, 2025
Review for Jake Needham

Verified Review
Aug 4, 2025
Review for Nathan Knorreck

Verified Review
Aug 1, 2025

She is truly incredible coach! I can't say enough positive things about Michelle. She is, without a doubt, one of the best CrossFit coaches I've ever had. From the moment I started, she has been an incredible source of knowledge, motivation, and positive energy. Michelle's encouragement is infectious. No matter the workout or how challenging it is, she always finds a way to make you believe in yourself. She celebrates every victory, big or small, and her enthusiasm makes even the toughest days feel manageable. Her ability to push you to your limits while keeping things fun and supportive is a rare talent. I am blessed to have her as a coach!

Verified Review
Aug 1, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

I got a good workout. Michelle is very helpful, knowledgeable, and patient. She gives a good pep-talk.

Verified Review
Jul 31, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Jul 31, 2025

Verified Review
Jul 31, 2025

Loved the tips Michelle shared with me to improve my static handstand holds. Very helpful!! Also, love her encouragement that keep us all going, especially during workouts like today’s that are mentally taxing!

Verified Review
Jul 30, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Jul 30, 2025

Verified Review
Jul 30, 2025
Review for Sue Plote

Verified Review
Jul 30, 2025
Review for Nathan Knorreck

Verified Review
Jul 29, 2025
Review for Phoebe Balentyne

Verified Review
Jul 29, 2025
Review for Nathan Knorreck

Nathan is a great coach! He knows the right thing to say to me to push me to the next level!

Verified Review
Jul 29, 2025
Review for Nathan Knorreck

She did excellent! I always feel seen no matter how many people are in the class. Encouragement? 10/10! I always feel like I can go heavier when Michelle coaches. 💪

Verified Review
Jul 29, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Carl is a super cool guy. He’s the most knowledgeable person on fitness training and sports science that I’ve ever meant face to face. He’s great at staying in tune to every single person in the class at the same time. The world has a lot to learn from him

Verified Review
Jul 29, 2025

Verified Review
Jul 29, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Verified Review
Jul 28, 2025
Review for Nathan Knorreck

Verified Review
Jul 26, 2025
Review for Gwendolyn Henderson

Verified Review
Jul 26, 2025
Review for Michelle Buntrock

Frequently Asked Questions

How many reviews does Sycamore CrossFit have?

Sycamore CrossFit currently has 80 verified member reviews with an average rating of 5 out of 5 stars. All reviews come from real members who have experienced the gym firsthand.

Are these reviews from real members?

Yes! All reviews are from verified members of Sycamore CrossFit. We collect authentic feedback directly from current and former members to help you make an informed decision about your fitness journey.

Can I filter reviews by coach?

Yes! Use the dropdown filter above to see reviews for specific coaches at Sycamore CrossFit. This helps you understand each coach's strengths and training style.

Where is Sycamore CrossFit located?

Sycamore CrossFit is located in Sycamore, Illinois at 1330 E State St, Sycamore, IL 60178, USA. Click the address above to get directions.