Sugar Creek CrossFit

Sugar Creek CrossFit

GymHappy Review:

"Beginners Find Confidence Without Intimidation"

5 /5

110 verified member reviews

What Members Are Saying

Members consistently highlight the supportive coaching and energizing atmosphere at Sugar Creek CrossFit, making it ideal for various fitness journeys.

  • ❤️ Fitness Beginners Find Confidence: Many first-timers report feeling welcomed and comfortable, with coaches providing clear explanations and modifications for unfamiliar movements, making their initial experiences enjoyable.
  • ❤️ Busy Professionals Maximize Efficiency: Reviewers appreciate the engaging and challenging workouts that fit into tight schedules, especially the early morning classes that energize them for the day ahead.
  • ❤️ Personal Accountability Fuels Progress: Members note the coaches' ongoing encouragement and check-ins, helping them stay consistent and motivated throughout their fitness journey.
  • ❤️ Strong Community Connections: Many express how the camaraderie among members fosters a welcoming environment, making them feel like they truly belong from day one.

AI summary based on recent reviews, updated weekly

Member Reviews

Verified Review
Dec 11, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Loved my first class today. Everything was thoroughly explained, my form was checked, and all of my questions were answered. Thanks!

Verified Review
Dec 3, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Carly is a great coach encouraging each individual to push themselves to become better athletes mentally and physically. She's your hype girl! This gym has athletes of all levels and a great group of people to be around. I encourage everyone to give it a shot at least once, you won't be disappointed.

Verified Review
Dec 3, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Thanks for the encouragement and the continued reminder to squat deeper!

Verified Review
Dec 2, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
Dec 2, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Always love the energy you bring to class. Appreciate the continuous coaching I always see you doing.

Verified Review
Nov 29, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
Nov 27, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Seth was an awesome coach I learned a lot he taught me different progressions of pull ups and gave me different techniques to improve my skill level I enjoyed myself

Verified Review
Nov 26, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 25, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 22, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

I just loved my first time working out! Robbie really helped me with technique and kept me in the loop with how things progressed! I will definitely be back for more! Thank you Robbie! ☺️

Verified Review
Nov 22, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
Nov 18, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Aaron and the rest of the class were super welcoming. Everyone was super supportive!

Verified Review
Nov 7, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 6, 2025
Review for Taylor Fraley

Verified Review
Nov 4, 2025

Robbie did great, always appreciate his warmup and instruction. Also the playlist was off the charts!

Verified Review
Oct 30, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
Oct 29, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Carly brings great energy to class, an amazing playlist, and you can tell she puts time and thought and intention into each class she teaches!

Verified Review
Oct 27, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Verified Review
Oct 21, 2025

Beth was so helpful today. My first ever cross fit class. She was great a helping with machines and moves I was unfamiliar with all during the workout. She was so motivating and encouraging during and after class! Loved it and will definitely return! Thank you

Verified Review
Oct 18, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Becca was great as always! Every movement was thoroughly explained and helpful critiques were given on form throughout the workout. Great coach!

Verified Review
Oct 18, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

My first experience trying CrossFit. My friend, Braden, invited me. Coach Carly was friendly and did a great job of welcoming me and explaining everything. It was a good workout and experience.

Verified Review
Oct 14, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Carly's classes are always fun!! She's very encouraging no matter what your goals are. She has great feedback about proper form. I always get a great workout when Carly teaches.

Verified Review
Oct 14, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Beth was a great coach for my first class! She explained everything well and made me feel comfortable and welcome. She was a great teacher. I had fun!

Verified Review
Oct 14, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Carly is a fantastic coach! She knows how to motivate and communicate all while not being overbearing or intimidating.

Verified Review
Oct 13, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Thanks for being patient and welcoming. Being rather new to CrossFit, trying to understand and learn the various names and techniques is a challenge.

Verified Review
Oct 10, 2025

It was so much fun! I felt like I belonged and not like an outsider.

Verified Review
Oct 8, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Taylor was exemplary. She really took the time to listen and understand concerning my mobility restrictions, and was knowledgeable, and practical when coming up with ways to modify the workout for me. She also loves Jesus which was by far the coolest part of my experience today, God bless 🙏🙌

Verified Review
Oct 7, 2025
Review for Taylor Fraley

Carly is very good at identifying the things you need to work on and helping you improve on them. She brings great energy to the class!

Verified Review
Sep 30, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Verified Review
Sep 24, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Aaron’s coaching was great. He explained the exercises clearly and in a timely manner. He was up beat and positive. Which was nice considering it was 0530 and I had no energy at the start.

Verified Review
Sep 24, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 19, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Coach Samantha is always an encouraging and supportive coach. She easily explains movements and standards to all levels. She is constantly engaging throughout class to help you improve. She is very skilled at catching small details in your movements to help you improve!

Verified Review
Sep 15, 2025
Review for Samantha Schubert

Robbie always brings the energy to class, whether it is at 5:30am or 5:30pm. He consistently provides great feedback during the class, and is always pushing people to their potential.

Verified Review
Sep 11, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Was my first class (ever). Sammy did an awesome job of working with me and keeping the class going and not slowing down the more experienced. Great first experience and I signed up on the spot.

Verified Review
Sep 8, 2025
Review for Samantha Schubert

Coach Samantha does an excellent job of explaining the movements of the day. She stays engaged with the class and walks around giving tips and encouragement.

Verified Review
Sep 8, 2025
Review for Samantha Schubert

Great class great energy!

Verified Review
Sep 8, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Carly was great!

Verified Review
Sep 6, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Carly is a great coach and always happy and peppy. She makes great workouts that keep things moving but doesn't hurt!

Verified Review
Sep 5, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

First time visiting, Kristin was a motivator! well trained and look forward to work out again.

Verified Review
Sep 2, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Good warmup that was specific to the workout as opposed to the regular routine. Cues were good in terms of breaking down the movements. She was paying attention and actively coaching and was able to offer tips.

Verified Review
Sep 2, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Robbie was welcoming and attentive. He heard my concerns and guided me in my exercise routine accordingly. I will be coming back. He did a great job!

Verified Review
Aug 29, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
Aug 26, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Amazing!!! Very motivating through the entirety of the class/workout! Thanks

Verified Review
Aug 15, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Beth is an awesome coach. She's knowledgeable, motivating, and fun to train with. She explains movements clearly, pushes you just enough, and keeps workouts challenging without feeling overwhelming. Easily one of the best parts of my CrossFit experience.

Verified Review
Aug 12, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Verified Review
Jul 18, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Class was enjoyable and productive! Becca was very sweet and helpful; she gave gentle and helpful instructions to a beginner. My goal was to get an idea of class and not hold anyone up, or embarrass myself. 😊 Becca was really helpful in proving suggestions and advice.

Verified Review
Jul 12, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Great coaching in a great environment! Always happy to drop in when we are in town.

Verified Review
Jul 7, 2025
Review for Samantha Schubert

Verified Review
Jul 1, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Verified Review
Jun 24, 2025
Review for Samantha Schubert

Super great! I had a blast!

Verified Review
Jun 18, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Robbie did great in motivating participants, and making sure everyone was prepared for the workout. The workout was challenging and fun.

Verified Review
Jun 16, 2025

I was nervous going in to this workout just because of the unknown. Carly made me feel so welcome and was very encouraging to work at my own pace but also push myself and keep going. Looking forward to future engine classes with her.

Verified Review
Jun 13, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Verified Review
Jun 11, 2025

Beth is wonderful! She’s encouraging, knowledgeable, and intentional. Her structured style helped keep class running smoothly and on schedule.

Verified Review
Jun 9, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Verified Review
Jun 6, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Robbie was extremely helpful, attentive, and made sure I felt comfortable at my first class! I will definitely be coming back!

Verified Review
Jun 6, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
Jun 3, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

I always appreciate her positive attitude and guidance with modification!

Verified Review
Jun 2, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Verified Review
May 31, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Brand new to CrossFit and Taylor made me feel super welcome and made sure I felt good about all the movements before getting into the workout. Will definitely be back & am excited to start this new journey at Sugar Creek!

Verified Review
May 28, 2025
Review for Taylor Fraley

Kristin was incredibly kind and welcoming. I walked in as a first timer, way out of shape, and nervous but she was encouraging and informative. Grade A Coach

Verified Review
May 27, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Verified Review
May 26, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
May 15, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Carly is awesome, personable, gives great cues and made class fun!

Verified Review
May 15, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Robbie was great! I really enjoyed his coaching while we were working on BMU skill work. :)

Verified Review
May 8, 2025

Robbie always brings great energy to the class. He takes time to explain things and is attentive to being sure things are done correctly and safely.

Verified Review
May 7, 2025

Carly has a passion for coaching and teaching everyone at all levels. She is knowledgeable and passionate about all CrossFit movements. She pushes you when you need it, and teaches you when you need it, which is what a good coach should do!

Verified Review
May 6, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Becca is hands down my hero. She’s fixed my gymnastics and helped me do ring muscle ups. I owe all my success to her.

Verified Review
May 6, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

I’ve been training with Beth at Sugar Creek CrossFit for around four months now, and it’s been one of the most rewarding experiences of my fitness journey. From the moment you walk into her class, you’re met with her infectious smile, unmatched energy, and genuine passion for helping others grow. Beth is not only incredibly knowledgeable—she leads by example and truly invests in every athlete. She’s your biggest supporter, always pushing you to become your best and helping you believe in your own potential. Whether it’s walking you through strategy before a workout or staying after class to debrief and encourage, Beth makes sure you get the absolute most out of every session. If you’re looking for a coach who inspires, educates, and truly cares, Beth is it.

Verified Review
May 5, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

What a fun day at Crossfit this morning!! My 13 yr old grandson and I look forward to Crossfit Sugar Creek workouts 3 times a week. Today was a PR day. My grandson is young and just learning what his body is capable of. Once he reached what he thought was his max for the day Coach Robbie focused in for the win. They were able to work together to safely add weight, increase confidence and safely get to an unexpected max PR. He left the Box with a super adrenaline high from a PR and a community round of 13 burpees where everyone celebrated his success and his birthday 🎂!!

Verified Review
May 2, 2025

Verified Review
May 1, 2025
Review for Bethany Brechbuhl

Stephanie was great to work with. This was my first CrossFit class and she made sure that I was aware of exactly what to do for each exercise. She also was in tune with some issues I have with my shoulders and knees and worked with me to make sure I did the exercises in ways that were conducive to what my body allows. All in all, great to work with her.

Verified Review
Apr 28, 2025
Review for Stephanie Weaver

Verified Review
Apr 25, 2025

Verified Review
Apr 25, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Beth is five stars! Friendly and motivating with a great coaching pace and helpful tips :)

Verified Review
Apr 24, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Great class! Tough workout!

Verified Review
Apr 19, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

10/10 Carly made me feel so welcome for my first class. She pushed me to do my best. Carly was very thorough when explaining the workout and each movement associated! I can’t wait to go back!

Verified Review
Apr 8, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

I appreciate Robbie being a healthy mix of patience and teaching with a bit of suck it up and get it done when needed

Verified Review
Apr 4, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Kept e

Verified Review
Apr 3, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

Verified Review
Apr 2, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Beth is a very attentive coach. I appreciated her workout-specific warm up and also her recommendations for modifications/baselines for deciding on weights. Overall a great class!

Verified Review
Apr 1, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Verified Review
Mar 29, 2025
Review for Taylor Fraley

Verified Review
Mar 19, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Carly is a great coach! Pushes every athlete to their full potential!

Verified Review
Mar 17, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Becca was awesome. Very welcoming and positive!

Verified Review
Mar 15, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Beth did a fantastic job. Explained movements well and helped encourage/push through the workout.

Verified Review
Mar 10, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Verified Review
Mar 10, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

It was awesome!

Verified Review
Mar 8, 2025
Review for Kristin Cooper

This class is perfect for me. I am able to see my limitations and work on them.

Verified Review
Mar 2, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Verified Review
Mar 1, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Verified Review
Feb 27, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Robbie was amazing! Very encouraging, understanding, and helpful! Made me feel right at home in his gym. kept me on track during the class so I didn’t get lost lol and did it all with a smile! Everyone at the gym was very friendly and welcoming! And the best part is I had fun!

Verified Review
Feb 25, 2025

Becca is THAT gorl. She will have more energy while simultaneously coaching and doing the workout than I have ever had in my life and she won’t run out of breath while hyping you up and running. Doesn’t hurt that she’s super cute too 😜

Verified Review
Feb 22, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Highly recommend checking out Sugar Creek CrossFit! The classes are ran extremely well and the people are super nice!

Verified Review
Feb 21, 2025

Great job. I appreciated her planning to ensure we stayed within the 1 hour time frame even though there was a lot to do in the class.

Verified Review
Feb 12, 2025
Review for Samantha Schubert

She did a good job encouraging me

Verified Review
Feb 8, 2025
Review for Samantha Schubert

Becca did an awesome job leading the class and tailoring the warmup for the workout of the day.

Verified Review
Feb 7, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Class was amazing! Becca always brings the energy I need to get through the grinder! I couldn't ask for more!

Verified Review
Feb 6, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

We had a great time. The gym was very welcoming & had a great vibe!

Verified Review
Feb 4, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
Feb 4, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

She kills it. As per usual. It’s hard and challenging and makes me want to die. But I love it, as she always makes it fun!

Verified Review
Feb 3, 2025
Review for Carly Edon

Robbie’s name isn’t on the coach list drop down menu above… but he did great today- As always.

Verified Review
Feb 1, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Verified Review
Feb 1, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Oh you already know it was hype, straight to the pump, and great coaching. Becca knows how to push you to your limits but will also always help you scale down and not hurt yo self.

Verified Review
Feb 1, 2025
Review for Becca Pankop

Robbie joined the class today and did the WOD with us. He was encouraging and upbeat, as usual. His enthusiasm a carried through from the moment he greeted me when I walked into the gym right up until the fist bump after finishing the workout.

Verified Review
Jan 31, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Great class and energy today!

Verified Review
Jan 31, 2025

Taylor is incredible-so supportive, and helps with each movement. She is so patient and meets you where you’re at while pushing you to be your best!

Verified Review
Jan 30, 2025
Review for Taylor Fraley

Great environment with even better coaching. If your looking for a home gym to workout in this is it.

Verified Review
Jan 30, 2025
Review for Robbie Williams

Beth is extremely kind and helpful! In such a fast pace environment she ensures every athlete is safe and understands what is going on.

Verified Review
Jan 27, 2025
Review for Beth Mitchell

Frequently Asked Questions

How many reviews does Sugar Creek CrossFit have?

Sugar Creek CrossFit currently has 110 verified member reviews with an average rating of 5 out of 5 stars. All reviews come from real members who have experienced the gym firsthand.

Are these reviews from real members?

Yes! All reviews are from verified members of Sugar Creek CrossFit. We collect authentic feedback directly from current and former members to help you make an informed decision about your fitness journey.

Can I filter reviews by coach?

Yes! Use the dropdown filter above to see reviews for specific coaches at Sugar Creek CrossFit. This helps you understand each coach's strengths and training style.

Where is Sugar Creek CrossFit located?

Sugar Creek CrossFit is located in Greenfield, Indiana at 3599 W US Hwy 40, Greenfield, IN 46140, USA. Click the address above to get directions.