CrossFit Mafia

CrossFit Mafia

GymHappy Review:

"Beginners Find Confidence Without Intimidation"

5 /5

176 verified member reviews

What Members Are Saying

Members consistently highlight the supportive atmosphere and personalized coaching at CrossFit Mafia, making it ideal for various fitness journeys.

  • ❤️ Beginners Find Confidence: First-time attendees express feeling welcomed and supported, with many noting the non-judgmental environment and helpful modifications provided by the coaches.
  • ❤️ Injury Recovery Seekers Feel Safe: Reviewers mention how instructors offer tailored modifications for injuries, ensuring a challenging yet safe workout experience for those returning from setbacks.
  • ❤️ Personalized Coaching Keeps You Accountable: Many appreciate the coaches' regular check-ins and tailored feedback, which helps them stay motivated and focused on their individual goals.
  • ❤️ Strong Community Bonds Foster Support: Members frequently mention the genuine camaraderie and encouragement shared among athletes, creating a motivating and engaging workout environment.

AI summary based on recent reviews, updated weekly

Member Reviews

Verified Review
Dec 13, 2025

Verified Review
Dec 13, 2025

Thank you for explaining each movement in such detail. You are not only our coach but also our mirror.

Verified Review
Dec 11, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Dec 8, 2025

Verified Review
Dec 5, 2025

I really love the community factor.

Verified Review
Dec 4, 2025

Though I’ve worked with several coaches in the past few years, and they’ve all helped me learn, Dave has been central in teaching me proper technique in all aspects of CrossFit. He’s passionate about getting it right. I see it in myself and in the other athletes he coaches.

Verified Review
Dec 3, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Dec 1, 2025

We really enjoyed the workout for Thanksgiving this morning! The session was perfectly timed and balanced - just the right mix of challenging movements and team spirit to make the holiday feel special. And especially the people! The gym community at CrossFit Mafia is genuinely welcoming and supportive; everyone was encouraging each other, sharing smiles, and celebrating each other's effort throughout the class. You have such a great gym community, and that made attending classes feel less like a workout and more like being part of something fun and motivating. We also really enjoyed attending classes at the gym when we can - the variety in workouts keeps things fresh, and the coaches always make sure each movement is done safely and effectively. And the music!!! The playlist was spot on with energetic, motivating tracks that kept us pushing through the toughest parts of the workout. It’s clear someone puts thought into matching the music to the pace of the exercises, which made a big difference in keeping the energy high. We wish we lived closer so we could attend more frequently and be part of this lively atmosphere every week! Thank you for having us and making the holiday workout something to look forward to.

Verified Review
Nov 27, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Nov 25, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Nov 21, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 21, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 20, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Nov 15, 2025

James sticks out among the coaches for technical expertise. If the work out calls for a barbell lift or some skill that I’ve never done before I’m usually checking the schedule to see if James is teaching because I know I will get useful technique and safety tips to keep me progressing and to keep me from getting hurt. He’s also really funny :-)

Verified Review
Nov 14, 2025

Heather is a great coach. She always checks in with me before the WOD to see what I’m going to do and if I feel comfortable with it all.

Verified Review
Nov 12, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 12, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 3, 2025

Verified Review
Nov 1, 2025

Today was my first day back after breaking my wrist and Brian was super helpful with modifications and support! I had a great and still challenging workout while still minding my surgeons restrictions!

Verified Review
Oct 31, 2025

Verified Review
Oct 28, 2025

Verified Review
Oct 25, 2025

Brian did a great job today! I have a lot of trouble with my form and I don’t like weights over my head. Brian’s coaching gave me confidence in the moves and I am very happy with my lifts today.

Verified Review
Oct 23, 2025

Dave is a wonderful coach! He has been patient, supportive and encouraging throughout my CrossFit journey. Thank you!

Verified Review
Oct 22, 2025

The workout is decadent but not overdone with cleans, double unders, wall walks, planks, sandbag carry, shoulder taps, and stretching. Full and very dense with mouth-coating tannins but also attractive fresh fruit, pretty acidity and a long finish. Rather chewy and needs time…. 95 points

Verified Review
Oct 18, 2025

I enjoyed my workout with Andrea. She was supportive and encouraging. She showed an interest in each athlete.

Verified Review
Oct 14, 2025

Brian is very detail oriented coach and I loved his warm up! He is also super welcoming and made sure we had everything we needed to have a good time :)

Verified Review
Oct 7, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Oct 7, 2025

Dave was great as always. I have never done a “snatch” before ane he expertly guided all of us thru it. His improvement points for each of us made it another great workout.

Verified Review
Oct 6, 2025

Always a great class with Christina, and she has a wonderfully non-judgemental coaching style to deliver the feedback I need to hear without making me feel completely inept.

Verified Review
Oct 6, 2025

Verified Review
Oct 3, 2025

Brian did awesome. Very knowledgeable. Even prepped by watching videos on RKB in Russian

Verified Review
Oct 3, 2025

Verified Review
Oct 2, 2025

Verified Review
Oct 2, 2025

Verified Review
Oct 1, 2025

Coach Christina did a great job today. She clearly explained the WOD, led us through a great warm up and answered any lingering questions athletes had. She made corrections to my form during the workout and encouraged me. Love taking an x-Tina class :)

Verified Review
Sep 29, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Coach Heather crushed it at Mafia this morning! Her clear instructions, feedback, and positive energy made a challenging workout fun. Great job!

Verified Review
Sep 29, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 29, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 29, 2025

Great work workout sessions

Verified Review
Sep 26, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Sep 26, 2025

Brian is great, he takes the time to check in with everyone in class and offers valuable feedback to help improve technique.

Verified Review
Sep 26, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 23, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 23, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 20, 2025

Dave Stover ensured right off the bat that he knew what condition I was in, as I hadn’t worked out in awhile. That meant a lot. Thanks Dave!

Verified Review
Sep 15, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Sep 12, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 11, 2025

Dropped in for a great class with Mike. Warm up was spot on and I will steal it for squat days at home.

Verified Review
Sep 10, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 10, 2025

Christina was awesome as usual! She is always so aware of my limitations and teaching me the best way to scale. She makes class fun which makes me eager to “get more fit”! Thanks, Christina!

Verified Review
Sep 8, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Sep 4, 2025

Verified Review
Sep 1, 2025

Brian was great! Very helpful and inclusive for my first time!

Verified Review
Sep 1, 2025

Christina was the coach of the class I went to and I loved her! Christina is fun, energetic, kind, motivating, and very knowledgeable - all the things you could want in a coach! The atmosphere of the gym was so positive and fun! Honestly had a great time.

Verified Review
Aug 30, 2025

Verified Review
Aug 29, 2025

Dave was a great coach! Explained the different exercises and always checked back to make sure my form was correct. Great atmosphere and great people!

Verified Review
Aug 27, 2025

Really enjoyed the fact that Brian spent some extra time helping me get some butterfly pull-ups. Very helpful tips and suggestions.

Verified Review
Aug 26, 2025

Dave and Jenn were great! Great warmup and there was good fluidity throughout the workout!

Verified Review
Aug 25, 2025

Verified Review
Aug 20, 2025

Coach Nrian

Verified Review
Aug 20, 2025

Verified Review
Aug 19, 2025

She’s one of the best coaches she always worries about our injuries and always has a backup, improves and help to do the best workout!

Verified Review
Aug 15, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Aug 12, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Aug 11, 2025

Brian is an awesome coach. I really appreciate that CrossFit Mafia coaches are able and willing to help each individual with where they are at and what they want to get out of a workout. Thanks for helping me with my technique and form today.

Verified Review
Aug 11, 2025

Verified Review
Aug 8, 2025

Verified Review
Aug 4, 2025

Christina is awesome as usual.

Verified Review
Jul 30, 2025

Verified Review
Jul 26, 2025

Always feel safe lifting with Brentnie. It's a good combo of a motivating push while also ensuring form is a priority.

Verified Review
Jul 25, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Thanks Brentie for a great class! Was really good and great to meet with the rest of the class as well!

Verified Review
Jul 18, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Heather is always amazing. She pushes you to do your best while making sure you are always using correct form.

Verified Review
Jul 18, 2025

Verified Review
Jul 16, 2025

Verified Review
Jul 12, 2025

Verified Review
Jul 11, 2025

Dre is great!!!!

Verified Review
Jul 8, 2025

Verified Review
Jul 8, 2025

Brian has quickly become one of my favorite coaches. Always challenging me to do a little bit more than I am capable of!

Verified Review
Jul 4, 2025

Andrea is always fun she explains the WOD very well asked for questions and how we can adjust the workout for each person. After the class. I’m tired for a little while and happy I did the class. Andrea is encouraging and stressed correct posture to not hurt our bodies. Good job Andrea!

Verified Review
Jun 29, 2025

Brian focuses on proper form while keeping individuals fitness goals in mind. Great coach!

Verified Review
Jun 26, 2025

Coach Brian was great, very positive and gave great scaling options. We really enjoyed the class!

Verified Review
Jun 26, 2025

Verified Review
Jun 22, 2025

James was excellent in demonstrating each of the movements and taking us through doing them properly. He is always encouraging to the students in the class.

Verified Review
Jun 5, 2025

Dropped in at the 5:30a with James today. Not only was the entire class welcoming, engaging and funny (not to mention strong AF), James made me feel incredibly welcomed. The warmup was really effective (I loved the wall ball partner activation), and the cues James gave (hips back) pushed me to be aware of my body. In addition, I appreciated how James gave cues to the class, not yelling and calling them out, but by their side, thoughtfully and effectively. Not to mention he’s funny and engaging and just led a really positive, engaging class. It’s obvious the culture that exists at Mafia - I can’t wait to come back.

Verified Review
May 30, 2025

Verified Review
May 29, 2025

Brian is a very patient and dedicated coach. He makes us do things safely and effectively. I love giving him a hard time when things get serious and I should go harder. Thanks B for pushing me!

Verified Review
May 28, 2025

Dave was the coach and I love working with him. He pushes me to strive for my best

Verified Review
May 27, 2025

Excellent

Verified Review
May 24, 2025

Today my coach was Dave! Super cool Guy. Very friendly and helpful. Haven’t been to CrossFit in a bit. The way he explained things was really helpful and made sense. Will be going back!

Verified Review
May 23, 2025

Great coach. she was very knowledgeable of the movements and helpful to those who needed scaled version of the exercises.

Verified Review
May 21, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
May 16, 2025

Verified Review
May 4, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Best class evvaaaaas

Verified Review
Apr 12, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

I think Heather is an excellent coach. She always offers ways to help correct my form to help me do more and is very motivating!

Verified Review
Apr 7, 2025

Verified Review
Apr 3, 2025

Verified Review
Mar 20, 2025

Verified Review
Mar 17, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Mar 12, 2025

Great instructor!

Verified Review
Mar 2, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Feb 21, 2025

James was incredibly welcoming, good sense of humor, and solid feedback and attention to detail on lifts. Really appreciated the experience!

Verified Review
Feb 21, 2025

Verified Review
Feb 19, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Brentnie is an amazing coach. She onboarded me as well. The class was good and she kept checking in on me.

Verified Review
Feb 8, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Coach Brian had great tips on body position when weightlifting and was very encouraging.

Verified Review
Feb 7, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Dave was great!

Verified Review
Feb 3, 2025

Verified Review
Jan 20, 2025

Verified Review
Jan 18, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Jan 16, 2025

Verified Review
Jan 8, 2025

Verified Review
Jan 3, 2025
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

A+

Verified Review
Dec 23, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

I always feel welcomed, even though I’m not an official member. Coaches check in and catch up with me every time and are genuinely kind and ensure my experience is good with the workout and gym. Brentnie’s energy while reviewing the workout and during is great. I appreciate the structure and seriousness brought to the workout when it’s time.

Verified Review
Dec 23, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Heather was awesome! I will be back!!

Verified Review
Dec 15, 2024

Coach Dave did a fantastic job of reviewing the proper form for squats and cleans

Verified Review
Dec 14, 2024

Verified Review
Dec 9, 2024

Learned something new today!

Verified Review
Dec 7, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Dec 3, 2024

Good deliberate warm up and lead in to the wod. Nice progression demos so everyone could scale with practice reps. I’m accustomed to having a lifting/strength portion so for me that was unusual but every gym is different. It was nice to not be rushed.

Verified Review
Nov 25, 2024

Dave and Jen are great instructors

Verified Review
Nov 20, 2024

Verified Review
Nov 13, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Coach Dave is always prepared and professional!

Verified Review
Nov 7, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Nov 5, 2024

Big class today to start of Bring A Friend week. Brentie was still able to get around to everyone and give us individualized suggestions for improvements. I really appreciate her feedback because she's able to provide different cues while waiting for one of them to click in my brain and body.

Verified Review
Nov 4, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Nov 4, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Oct 19, 2024

Verified Review
Oct 17, 2024

Way to kick my ass, Dave! Great workout!

Verified Review
Oct 14, 2024

Absolutely LOVE Crossfit Mafia! The coaches are exceptional—dedicated to proper warm-ups, cool-downs, and, most importantly, ensuring you maintain correct form to prevent injury. The workouts are fun yet challenging, and the coaches and community consistently push you to achieve goals you never thought possible. The atmosphere is unmatched—everyone welcomes you with open arms and cheers you on every step of the way. I never imagined I’d be excited to wake up at 5:30 a.m. for a workout, but Crossfit Mafia has made it happen!

Verified Review
Oct 7, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Sep 25, 2024

Great workout, helpful coaching + supportive and encouraging!

Verified Review
Sep 23, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Very informational and helpful on my OHS and Dips!

Verified Review
Sep 10, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Sep 5, 2024

New to this box and am excited to continue my journey here. Brentnie's class was instructed very well, tips and proper form was relayed in a professional manner!

Verified Review
Sep 4, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Sep 4, 2024

Verified Review
Sep 3, 2024

Coach Dave and Jen were great as always

Verified Review
Sep 3, 2024

Verified Review
Aug 30, 2024

The community here was great! Gym is gorgeous, accommodating, and very clean. The programming and coaching is everything that one would want in a CrossFit gym. We will definitely be back again!

Verified Review
Aug 24, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Workout was intense and fun!

Verified Review
Aug 24, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Great! Easy to follow along and got some great tips for my pull-ups and run pacing.

Verified Review
Aug 20, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Loved the flow of class and could tell she was a CrossFit instructor. Took time with every person in class. I would join this gym if I lived here.

Verified Review
Aug 13, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Aug 8, 2024

Verified Review
Aug 8, 2024

Verified Review
Aug 2, 2024

Verified Review
Aug 1, 2024

Verified Review
Jul 27, 2024

Heather was my coach today as she was awesome!! Love the gym and the other class members were so welcoming too :). I’ll be back!

Verified Review
Jul 26, 2024

This review is for Coach Brian ... Day: Monday, July 8th, 2024 Class: 6:30AM As a general statement - all coaches at CrossFit Mafia are great. And each coach brings their unique talents to every class. Which is another reason why CrossFit Mafia is so great. Brian is a great coach. He helps motivate people to do their best and to push a bit beyond their comfort zone. He is diligent in providing feedback during the WOD and making sure people are using the right form in order to avoid injury. One thing Brian can improve on is presenting personalized scaling options and making sure everyone has a plan before the WOD starts. As Brian gets to know the members better, this will come naturally. Overall 5-Stars!

Verified Review
Jul 8, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Jul 4, 2024

Verified Review
Jun 17, 2024

Verified Review
Jun 14, 2024

Verified Review
Jun 10, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
Jun 8, 2024

I’m new to crossfit but Brian was so helpful guiding me thru everything we did. I had so much fun. I’ve gone 2 days in a row! Such a great community.

Verified Review
Jun 5, 2024

Coach Brian did great today. He walked me through a great progression to get to where I needed to be.

Verified Review
Jun 4, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
May 31, 2024

Verified Review
May 31, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
May 30, 2024

Verified Review
May 30, 2024

Verified Review
May 30, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Ehla was awesome! Amazing Gym

Verified Review
May 26, 2024

Owner/Coach Brentnie is 10/10! She knows exactly how to scale the WOD to my fitness level and abilities. She demos each movement which is awesome to make sure you are performing the movement safely. Lastly, the encouragement during the workout is top notch, she makes sure you’re still getting the work done, but there when you need a jolt of energy!

Verified Review
May 24, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Awesome coaching, community and box!

Verified Review
May 23, 2024

Verified Review
May 20, 2024

Super nice and helpful with suggestions to modify.

Verified Review
May 18, 2024

I love Dave and Jenn as coaches!!

Verified Review
May 8, 2024

Awesome class with Jonathan!

Verified Review
May 7, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Verified Review
May 6, 2024

Verified Review
May 6, 2024

Verified Review
May 3, 2024

Verified Review
May 1, 2024

Verified Review
May 1, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Brentnie is a wonderful coach with SO much knowledge!! Love taking her classes!

Verified Review
May 1, 2024
Review for Brentnie Kincaid

Dave is always so very good at making sure we are doing the exercises correctly, & doing our best. He is very helpful & encouraging.

Verified Review
Apr 30, 2024

Verified Review
Apr 30, 2024

Frequently Asked Questions

How many reviews does CrossFit Mafia have?

CrossFit Mafia currently has 176 verified member reviews with an average rating of 5 out of 5 stars. All reviews come from real members who have experienced the gym firsthand.

Are these reviews from real members?

Yes! All reviews are from verified members of CrossFit Mafia. We collect authentic feedback directly from current and former members to help you make an informed decision about your fitness journey.

Can I filter reviews by coach?

Yes! Use the dropdown filter above to see reviews for specific coaches at CrossFit Mafia. This helps you understand each coach's strengths and training style.

Where is CrossFit Mafia located?

CrossFit Mafia is located in Erie, Colorado at 3000 Airport Dr Building 502 A, Erie, CO 80516, USA. Click the address above to get directions.